MOCASE: The agroecological movement defending land and the peasantry in Santiago del Estero, Argentina

Over de thesis van Marthe Cressato
The defense of land: MOCASE's reaction to the expanding agricultural frontier in Santiago del Estero, Argentina (2024)
Promotor(en) Joost Dessein, Faculteit Bio-ingenieurswetenschappen
SDG 2 – Geen honger | SDG 10 – Ongelijkheid verminderen | SDG 11 – Duurzame steden en gemeenschappen | SDG 12 – Verantwoorde consumptie en productie | SDG 15 – Leven op het land | SDG 16 – Vrede, veiligheid en sterke publieke diensten
Marthe Cressato
Redactie door
Green Office
It is widely known that the heightened global demand for soy leads to deforestation of the Amazon rainforest. But the so-called soyization of the South American agriculture system extends more broadly. In Santiago del Estero, a rural province in the northwest of Argentina, peasants bundled forces together in 1990 to defend their land against big, mainly soy agribusinesses. They founded the movement named MOCASE and are opposing the expanding agricultural frontier ever since. Along the way the movement has grown a lot, both in size and mission. For example, they adopted the agroecology framework which connects the movement with peasant movements worldwide. Why and how the peasants defend their land will be explored in this article.

Introducing MOCASE, the peasant movement of Santiago del Estero

Santiago, del Estero, a semi-arid province with high precarious land tenure without legal status, has a primarily rural population and an unequal distribution of land. In this context, the so-called agricultural frontier is extending. Land that has been used for centuries by peasant communities is (il)legally acquired by agribusinesses.

In 1990 following an increase in (violent) land conflicts, MOCASE was founded by peasants. Ever since, the horizontal movement organizes and emancipates peasants to defend their way of living on and off the land. MOCASE uses the agroecological framework, exemplified by the popular education through the “escuela de agroecologia”.


The flag of MOCASE, hung at a community meeting. Picture by Marthe Cressato

Agroecology: one term, a plethora of interpretations

The term agroecology encompasses many definitions and is used in the sense of a science, a set of agricultural practices, and a movement. The latter angle is of importance in the context of MOCASE. Agroecology emerged as a social movement in the wake of the Green Revolution and generally strives for sustainable agriculture based on local knowledge often with the aim of acquiring food sovereignty.

Rural social movements are increasingly adopting the agroecology framework. It is used to frame the immaterial territories, such as ideas or theoretical constructs, which always underlie material territories, for example contested land (Fernandes, 2009). Agroecology also links peasant movements together, for example in the international movement La Via Campesina.

A member of MOCASE showing his terrain while sharing his experiences on the land. Picture by Marthe Cressato

The defense of land

“The main strategy is, in my opinion, living there, producing there, being there. [...] So that the communities feel that they are part of the land, they are the land.”

-MOCASE member, interview, 2024

The primary way MOCASE continuously defends the land is by promoting and upholding the peasantry and by strengthening and organizing communities through regular meetings, assemblies, workshops, community kitchens, educating peasant students in the agroecological school and at the peasant university.

The defense of land intensifies when a conflict surges and (armed) groups of people, hired by a businessman, try to enter a terrain of a peasant family. At those times the movement quickly and numerously gathers and begins the physical vigilance to keep the (armed) people from entering, killing animals, destructing crops and houses, intimidating the families, …

During lengthy land conflicts, MOCASE puts up carpas the defensa, tents from which the community stays on guard to defend the peasant land. Picture by Marthe Cressato

Agroecology in MOCASE

“Yes, for us agroecology is, more than anything, producing healthily, sane. We want to produce to feed the people. So that is what we defend. We defend the education, the territory, we defend the production”

-MOCASE member, interview, 2024

The previous quote points to the significance of agroecology within the movement: the way of producing, the way of living on and off the land, in short, the peasantry. By defending agroecology, the movement defends the peasantry and their land. Agroecology lends itself to various interpretations, making it applicable in diverse contexts.

As previously introduced, MOCASE uses the agroecology framework during conflicts over immaterial territories. To exemplify, the interpretation of a ‘productive land use’ is an immaterial territory: agribusiness sees it as maximizing yields and profits, while peasant communities aim for current and future self-sufficiency. Agroecology, with its focus on food sovereignty and sustainable practices, aligns with the peasants’ beliefs and ideas.

Forming one front, locally and globally

In the province of Santiago del Estero, peasants successfully form one front to defend their land against agribusinesses under the flag of MOCASE and use agroecology as the common denominator to describe their diverse ways of living on and off the land. The force of the movement lies in the ability to unite peasants:

“With the people from the community united, it is easier to defend one’s rights, otherwise... Alone I can not defend anything. Your rights, you can not defend it on your own as a family, alone it is really hard. Rather, in community, with many, yes [it’s possible]”

-MOCASE member, interview, 2024

On a global scale, a similar phenomenon takes place. Peasant movements, MOCASE one of them, came together and formed La Via Campesina, the international peasant movement. LVC also adopted the agroecology framework to defend contested rural spaces. Rosset and Martínez-Torres (2012) explain the need for these worldwide alliances:

 “Social movements comprising peasants and other rural peoples are actively defending spaces from, and contesting them with, these agribusinesses and other private sector actors and their allies in governments. Because the private sector is typically transnational in nature, peasant social movements have increasingly organized into transnational alliances”

-Rosset and Martínez-Torres, 2012

References

Fernandes, B. M. (2009). Sobre a tipologia de territórios. In Territórios e territorialidades: teoria, processos e conflitos, pages 197–215. Expressão Popular, Sao Paulo, Brazil.

Rosset, P. M. and Martínez-Torres, M. E. (2012). Rural Social Movements and Agroecology: Context, Theory, and Process. Ecology and Society, 17(3):art17.

Over Marthe Cressato

Met de motivatie om oplossingen te vinden voor de klimaatsverandering begon ik in 2019 aan mijn studie bio-ingenieurswetenschappen. Op dat pad ging ik verder en koos ik voor de master genaamd Land, Water en Klimaat. Onderweg kwam ik echter tot het inzicht dat “pure” wetenschap ontoereikend is, en werd mijn sluimerende interesse voor sociale wetenschappen aangewakkerd. Via mijn thesis keek ik met een andere bril naar een landvraagstuk en leerde ik agroecologie kennen, wat ik super interessant vond en graag mee verder wil in de toekomst. Momenteel ben ik echter terug bij de natuurwetenschappen en doe ik een traineeship bij UNESCO in Parijs, meer specifiek binnen de sectie genaamd “Hydrological Systems, Climate Change and Adaptation”. Hiermee duik ik voor het eerst in de beleids- en diplomatieke wereld en werk ik mee aan projecten die via wetenschap complexe klimaat-gerelateerde watervraagstukken proberen op te lossen.